Push Pin vs Threaded Flat Backs for Fresh Piercings: Pros, Cons, and Healing

Quick answer

For fresh piercings, both push pin and threaded flat back earrings offer secure, comfortable wear, but push pin styles are easier to insert and remove, making them ideal for beginners. Threaded flat backs provide a more traditional, secure fit but require more dexterity. Choose push pin for simplicity and threaded for a classic, secure hold.

When you get a new piercing, the jewelry you choose can make a big difference in healing and comfort. Flat back earrings are a popular choice because they sit flush against the skin, reducing irritation and snagging. But within the flat back category, you have two main options: push pin (also called bolt) and threaded flat backs. Each has its own set of pros and cons.

In this comparison, we'll look at how push pin and threaded flat backs differ in terms of insertion, security, and healing. We'll also share some product examples to help you see what's available. By the end, you'll know which style suits your new piercing best.

What Are Push Pin Flat Back Earrings?

Push pin flat back earrings, also known as bolt flat backs, feature a post with a small indentation or notch near the end. The flat back piece has a spring mechanism that snaps onto the post, locking it in place. This design allows for easy one-handed insertion and removal, which is great for people who are new to changing jewelry.

The main advantage of push pin flat backs is convenience. You simply push the back onto the post until it clicks, and you're done. No twisting or screwing required. This makes them a favorite for those who change their earrings frequently or have limited dexterity. However, some people worry about the security of the spring mechanism, but when properly fitted, it holds securely.

• Push pin backs are easier to insert and remove than threaded backs.
• They are ideal for those who are new to wearing flat back earrings.

What Are Threaded Flat Back Earrings?

Threaded flat back earrings have a post with external threads and a flat back that screws onto the post. This traditional design has been used for years and is known for its secure hold. The screw-on mechanism ensures that the back won't accidentally come off, which is reassuring for those who worry about losing earrings.

The downside is that threaded backs require more effort to put on and take off. You need to align the threads and twist the back onto the post, which can be fiddly, especially with small earrings. This might be a challenge for people with shaky hands or those who are in a hurry. But once it's on, it's on securely.

• Threaded backs offer a very secure fit that won't loosen over time.
• They require more dexterity to attach and remove compared to push pin backs.

Healing Considerations for Fresh Piercings

When it comes to healing, both push pin and threaded flat backs have similar benefits. The flat back design minimizes pressure on the piercing site and reduces the risk of irritation from snagging on clothing or hair. This is crucial for new piercings, which need to be left undisturbed as much as possible.

The main difference in healing comes down to how often you need to handle the jewelry. Push pin backs are easier to remove and reinsert, which can be helpful if you need to clean the area or change jewelry during the healing process. Threaded backs, being more secure, might be less likely to be fiddled with, which could be a plus for some. Ultimately, both are good choices for healing as long as you choose high-quality, hypoallergenic materials.

• Flat back designs are gentle on healing piercings.
• Choose materials like medical-grade titanium to avoid allergic reactions.

Push Pin vs Threaded: Trade-offs at a Glance

• Ease of use: Push pin backs are easier to insert and remove, while threaded backs require twisting and more dexterity. Choose push pin if you're a beginner or prefer quick changes.
• Security: Threaded backs provide a very secure screw-on hold, while push pin backs rely on a spring mechanism that is secure but may feel less solid to some. Choose threaded if you worry about backs coming off.
• Healing: Both styles offer a flat back that reduces irritation. Push pin backs may be easier to remove for cleaning, but both are suitable for healing piercings if the jewelry is high-quality. Both are good; just pick the one you're more comfortable handling.

Product Examples and Why They Matter

• Sphere Push Pin Flat Back Earring, 3mm: This earring is available as a pair for lobe piercings (20g/6mm) in our signature Sphere Nap Earrings, 3mm. It features a perfect sphere and is sold as singles. The post gauge options are 16g, 18g, or 20g, and post lengths are 6mm or 8mm. It's best for healed cartilage or lobe piercings. Push pin flat backs like this one are easy to insert and remove, making them a convenient choice for those who want to switch up their ear stack without hassle. The 20g/6mm option is suitable for standard lobe piercings, but note it's best for healed piercings, not fresh ones.



• Classic Cartilage Hoop: This hoop is perfectly understated and minimalist. It's available in gauges 16g, 18g, or 20g, with internal diameters of 6mm or 8mm. It's best for healed cartilage piercings and is sold as singles. The materials include medical-grade titanium with 14K gold PVD plating or platinum PVD plating. While not a flat back, this hoop shows an alternative for healed cartilage piercings. If you're considering hoops later, knowing your gauge and diameter is essential. For fresh piercings, flat backs are generally recommended over hoops to minimize movement.

Which Should You Choose?

Best for

• Push pin flat backs are best for people who want easy, tool-free insertion and removal, especially for everyday wear or for those new to flat back earrings.
• Threaded flat backs are best for those who prioritize maximum security and don't mind a bit more effort when changing jewelry.

Not for

• Push pin flat backs may not be ideal for those who are concerned about the spring mechanism loosening over time.
• Threaded flat backs may not be suitable for people with limited hand dexterity or who need to change earrings frequently.

Both push pin and threaded flat back earrings are excellent choices for fresh piercings, offering comfort and security. Your decision comes down to personal preference: go with push pin for convenience and ease, or choose threaded for a classic, secure fit. Whichever you pick, prioritize high-quality materials like medical-grade titanium to support healthy healing.