Two backings, two different hold systems
The threaded ball back and the push pin flat back both keep an earring in place, but they secure the post in different ways. A threaded ball back screws onto the post; a push pin flat back uses a push-pin mechanism to lock the post. That mechanical difference affects how each feels day to day, how you replace parts, and what you need to check before buying.
This comparison sticks to what the supplied product records confirm. The Pave Moon Push Pin Flat Back Earring (product 3434367) and the Solid 14k Gold Threaded Ball Back (product 3434471) give us concrete details on sizing, materials, and compatibility. Where the records are silent, we flag it rather than guess.
Security and hold: what each design confirms
- Threaded ball back: The Solid 14k Gold Threaded Ball Back is a 3mm ball backing that threads onto the earring post. The record says it is suitable for solid gold ball back earrings only and will not fit earrings designed for traditional butterfly backings. That threaded connection is the security mechanism: the backing screws on rather than pressing on.
- Push pin flat back: The Pave Moon Push Pin Flat Back Earring uses a push-pin post. The record lists gauges of 16g (1.2mm), 18g (1mm), or 20g (0.8mm) and post lengths of 6mm or 8mm. It is sold as singles and is best for healed cartilage or lobe piercings. The record does not describe the locking mechanism in detail, so we cannot say how it compares to threading in holding force.
Pave Moon Push Pin Flat Back: confirmed sizing and materials
- Pave Moon Push Pin Flat Back Earring: Earring top: 6mm tall x 3mm wide; post gauge: 16g (1.2mm), 18g (1mm), or 20g (0.8mm); post length: 6mm or 8mm. These are the numbers you need to match your piercing gauge and desired fit. A 20g post suits lobe and nose piercings per the variant names, while 16g is listed for most cartilage piercings.

Pave Moon Push Pin Flat Back Earring - Pave Moon Push Pin Flat Back Earring: Made of medical-grade titanium with cubic zirconia crystals and 18K gold PVD plating; described as hypoallergenic, waterproof, and tarnish resistant. Material matters for daily wear and sensitive skin. The record supports these claims for this specific earring, so you can weigh them against your own needs.
- Pave Moon Push Pin Flat Back Earring: Sold as singles; available as a pair for lobe piercings (20g/6mm) in the Pave Moon Nap Earrings. If you need a pair for lobes, the 20g/6mm pair option exists. For cartilage, you order singles, which helps if you are mixing gauges or replacing one earring.
Solid 14k Gold Threaded Ball Back: compatibility and replacement
- Solid 14k Gold Threaded Ball Back: 3mm ball back, sold individually; for a pair, order two. The 3mm size is compact and the individual sale makes it easy to replace a single lost backing without buying a full set.

Solid 14k Gold Threaded Ball Back - Solid 14k Gold Threaded Ball Back: Suitable for solid gold ball back earrings only; threaded and will not fit earrings designed for traditional butterfly backings. This is the key compatibility check. Before buying, confirm your earring is a solid gold ball back style with a threaded post. It will not work with push pin or butterfly-back earrings.
Which backing suits your piercing and routine?
If you wear healed cartilage or lobe piercings and want a flat back that sits flush, the Pave Moon Push Pin Flat Back gives you gauge and length choices (16g, 18g, 20g; 6mm or 8mm) plus a titanium build with gold PVD plating. The record describes it as hypoallergenic, waterproof, and tarnish resistant, and notes it is best for healed piercings. That makes it a practical daily-wear option for many people, though the record does not detail the push-pin locking mechanism.
If you already own solid gold ball back earrings and need a replacement backing, the Solid 14k Gold Threaded Ball Back is the targeted fix. It is a 3mm threaded ball that screws onto compatible posts. The tradeoff is narrow compatibility: it will not fit butterfly-back or push-pin earrings, so check your earring style first. For a pair, order two.
Neither record gives a pull-test rating or a universal security score, so choose based on fit and compatibility rather than a claimed holding force. The threaded back relies on screw threads; the push pin relies on its pin mechanism. Both can stay put when correctly matched to the earring and piercing.
Care and longevity notes from the records
The Pave Moon record says to polish with a soft cloth to maintain shine. It also lists the earring as waterproof and tarnish resistant, but that does not mean you should skip routine cleaning. The Solid 14k Gold Threaded Ball Back record does not include care instructions beyond its material (solid 14k gold) and compatibility notes, so follow general good practice for gold jewelry and avoid harsh chemicals.
For either backing, check tightness periodically. Threaded backs can loosen over time; push-pin backs should be seated firmly. The records do not specify how often to check, so use your own judgment based on daily wear.



